This is a review article of the Urinary care diets produced by Hill’s, both the dry and wet food. In this review, it will touch on the following topics surrounding the Urinary care diets.
- Legal action against prescription pet food
- The companies behind prescription diets
- What’s in Urinary care dog food?
- Why Veterinarians sell this food?
- Your next steps.
Legal action against prescription pet food
Because the foods are so low quality, their association with Vets is being considered as deceptive and their marketing as being “different to normal dog foods” as fraudulent.
MOORE V. MARS PETCARE US – California Court of Appeals 2020
“The panel concluded that under the reasonable consumer test, plaintiffs sufficiently alleged that the sale of the prescription pet food exclusively through vets or with veterinarian approval was a deceptive practice.
Also, plaintiffs satisfied the heightened pleading standard for fraud because they alleged sufficient facts to show that prescription pet food and other pet food were not materially different.”
Not to mention the foods recalls due to dog deaths.
In 2019, Hills had one of the biggest food recalls ever. Around 22 million cans of their food had to be recalled because Vitamin D levels in tested lots were 33 times the recommended safe limit.
Attorney Nyran Rose Rasch – “We believe that hundreds, if not thousands, of pets have died or become seriously ill as a result of eating Hill’s foods with toxic levels of Vitamin D,” says
The FDA investigation found that the vitamin premix had not been analysed and that the final product had not been tested to determine that it met Hill’s specific formulation. Plus, Hill’s failed to obtain certificates of analysis from the supplier of the vitamin.
Who makes the prescription diet?
Hill’s (Colgate) began selling its “Prescription Diet” pet food in the 1960s through vets. In 2004, when Hill’s became a significant player in the prescription pet food market, Royal Canin (Mars) introduced its own line of prescription pet food. At an unspecified time prior to 2012, Purina (Nestle) entered the prescription pet food market.
Hills – Colgate
Royal Canin – Mars
Purina – Nestlé
Not known for their health food products or trustworthy marketing tactics.
What’s in the food?
- Animal by-products – animal fats, digest (see how bad these are below)
- Brewers Rice – Low quality carb filler, unnatural for dogs.
- Dried whole egg – powdered egg, extremely low quality protein source
- Maize starch– Maize connected to allergies and intolerances by holistic vets
- Soybean Oil – Soy connected to allergies and intolerance by holistic vets
- Animal by-products – Animal fats (see how bad these are below)
- Dried egg – Powdered egg is not a quality protein.
- Maize starch – connected to allergies and intolerances by holistic vets.
- Rice and rice flour – too high in rice, high grain diets are unnatural for dogs
- Various sugars – ???
Here’s a look at what can go into animal-by products:
Why is it recommended by Vets?
In the UK there are seven universities offering degrees in veterinary science. Nutrition however, plays a minor role in their education.
The average Vet only receiving 19 hours of nutrition training for all animals.
To put that into context, I’d say I’ve spent 1hr per day learning about canine nutrition (low end), 5hrs per week (not weekends) for the last 3.5 years.
I’ve spent around 910hrs learning about dog nutrition, just dogs.
A lack of education and chronic underfunding (or in some cases just greed), many universities are very open to external sources of revenue and are happy to accept ‘sponsorship’ from companies despite glaring conflicts of interest. Over the decades, The Big Three (Colgate, Mars and Nestle) have exploited this situation to develop ever closer ties with vet schools around the world, providing funding and education.
The Nutrition Textbooks
The most popular text on the subject, entitled “Small Animal Clinical Nutrition” is made by Hill’s. They also make the accompanying “Quick Consult” guide and the “Key to Clinical Nutrition”. Royal Canin’s best-known texts are the Encyclopedia of Canine Clinical Nutrition and the Encyclopedia of Feline Clinical Nutrition.
It probably won’t surprise you to hear that these texts are not what most people would call ‘impartial’ on the subject of pet food.
As an example, the Canine Encyclopaedia dedicates more space to promoting Soy Protein Isolate Hydrolysate (a common Royal Canin ingredient) than it does to exploring the entire subject of home-preparing a fresh food diet.
The very last sentence in the entire textbook perfectly summarises how Royal Canin consider your sick pets: “Ideally, space should be organized in such a way that owners are led to buy a new supply of food for their dog, and even to buy new products for the dog that they have not seen before (e.g., chewing bars for dental hygiene)”.
This book is one of the primary sources of information on pet nutrition for vets. Unfortunately, your Vet knows little to nothing about nutrition.
Your next steps
The power of food is that it can make a dog healthier. Just like with us humans, when we start eating a super healthy diet, it undoes the damage of an unhealthy diet.
Read my blog post on making homemade diets for dogs with Urinary disease.
Or check out my specifically formulated recipe book, for every dog and their specific stage.
The healthiest and most cost effective way to feed your dog is homemade food.